URS FINAL DETERMINATION
IBM Corporation v. ecawen pyle et al.
Claim Number: FA1510001640452
DOMAIN NAME
<ibm.lol>
PARTIES
Complainant: IBM Corporation of Armonk, NY, United States of America | |
Respondent: ecawen Zhao Chunkai of china, --, China | |
REGISTRIES and REGISTRARS
Registries: Uniregistry, Corp. | |
Registrars: Uniregistrar Corp |
EXAMINER
The undersigned certifies that he or she has acted independently and impartially and to the best of his or her knowledge has no known conflict in serving as Examiner in this proceeding. | |
Mr. Sebastian Matthew White Hughes, as Examiner |
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Complainant Submitted: October 1, 2015 | |
Commencement: October 2, 2015 | |
Response Date: October 14, 2015 | |
Having reviewed the communications records, the Examiner finds that the Forum has discharged its responsibility under URS Procedure Paragraphs 3 and 4 and Rule 4 of the Rules for the Uniform Rapid Suspension System (the "Rules"). |
RELIEF SOUGHT
Complainant requests that the domain name be suspended for the life of the registration. |
STANDARD OF REVIEW
Clear and convincing evidence. |
FINDINGS and DISCUSSION
Findings of Fact: [OptionalComment] |
URS Procedure 1.2.6, requires Complainant to prove, by clear and convincing evidence, each of the following three elements to obtain an order that a domain name should be suspended.
[URS 1.2.6.1] The registered domain name(s) is/are identical or confusingly similar
to a word mark: Determined: Finding for Complainant The registered domain name is identical to Complainant's registered IBM word marks. The Examiner notes that Complainant has, erroneously, in the Complaint quoted URS 1.2.6.1 as follows "The registered domain name(s) is/are identical or confusingly similar to a word or mark [URS/.usRS 1.2.6.1]: for which the Complainant holds a valid national or regional registration and that is in current use." Complainant has also, in addition to exhibiting various registration certificates for the word mark IBM, exhibited registration certificates for a stylized version of the IBM mark which, in the Examiner's opinion, do not constitute word mark registrations for the purposes of URS 1.2.6.1. Accordingly, the latter can have no bearing on these proceedings. Complainant appears to be labouring under the misapprehension that the URS procedure applies to non-word trademarks. Complainant has, however, provided evidence of its valid registrations for the IBM word mark, and also relies on the registration of its IBM word mark with the Trademarks Clearinghouse. Accordingly, the first limb of the URS procedure has been made out. [URS 1.2.6.2] Registrant has no legitimate right or interest to the domain name. Determined: Finding for Complainant Respondent has failed to adduce any evidence to demonstrate any legitimate right or interest. Respondent simply asserts that the domain name was registered after the <.lol> sunrise period has expired, and suggests, erroneously, that the use of the registered domain name in China (where Complainant has a strong reputation in its IBM mark) can be of no concern to Complainant.
[URS 1.2.6.3] The domain name(s) was/were registered and is being used in bad faith.
Determined: Finding for Complainant Complainant's IBM mark is well-known. There can be no question Respondent must have known of Complainant and it's trademark rights when it registered the domain name. FINDING OF ABUSE or MATERIAL FALSEHOOD The Examiner may find that the Complaint was brought in an abuse of this proceeding or that it contained material falsehoods. Respondent has alleged that the Complaint was brought in an abuse of this proceeding or that it contained material falsehoods. The Examiner finds as follows:
DETERMINATION
After reviewing the parties’ submissions, the Examiner determines that the Complainant
has demonstrated all three elements of the URS by a standard of clear and convincing
evidence; the Examiner hereby Orders the following domain name(s) be SUSPENDED for
the duration of the registration:
|
Mr. Sebastian Matthew White Hughes
Click Here to return to the main Domain Decisions Page.
Click Here to return to our Home Page