
DECISION
Digital Insurance LLC v. JIM BIANCHI / BCA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.
Claim Number: FA2610002250504
PARTIES
Complainant is Digital Insurance LLC ("Complainant"), represented by Ashley N. Klein of Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP, Georgia, USA. Respondent is JIM BIANCHI / BCA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. ("Respondent"), Massachusetts, USA.
REGISTRAR AND DISPUTED DOMAIN NAME
The domain name at issue is <bcabenefitsgroup.com> ("Domain Name"), registered with Bluehost Inc.
PANEL
The undersigned certifies that they have acted independently and impartially and to the best of their knowledge have no known conflict in serving as Panelist in this proceeding.
Nicholas J.T. Smith as Panelist.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Complainant submitted a Complaint to Forum electronically on October 13, 2026; Forum received payment on October 13, 2026.
On October 20, 2026, Bluehost Inc. confirmed by e-mail to Forum that the <bcabenefitsgroup.com> domain name is registered with Bluehost Inc. and that Respondent is the current registrant of the name. Bluehost Inc. has verified that Respondent is bound by the Bluehost Inc. registration agreement and has thereby agreed to resolve domain disputes brought by third parties in accordance with ICANN's Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the "Policy").
On October 21, 2026, Forum served the Complaint and all Annexes, including a Written Notice of the Complaint, setting a deadline of November 10, 2026 by which Respondent could file a Response to the Complaint, via e-mail to all entities and persons listed on Respondent's registration as technical, administrative, and billing contacts, and to postmaster@bcabenefitsgroup.com. Also on October 21, 2026, the Written Notice of the Complaint, notifying Respondent of the e-mail addresses served and the deadline for a Response, was transmitted to Respondent via post and fax, to all entities and persons listed on Respondent's registration as technical, administrative and billing contacts.
Having received no response from Respondent, Forum transmitted to the parties a Notification of Respondent Default.
On November 11, 2026, pursuant to Complainant's request to have the dispute decided by a single-member Panel, Forum appointed Nicholas J.T. Smith as Panelist.
Having reviewed the communications records, the Administrative Panel (the "Panel") finds that Forum has discharged its responsibility under Paragraph 2(a) of the Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the "Rules") "to employ reasonably available means calculated to achieve actual notice to Respondent" through submission of Electronic and Written Notices, as defined in Rule 1 and Rule 2. Therefore, the Panel may issue its decision based on the documents submitted and in accordance with the ICANN Policy, ICANN Rules, Forum's Supplemental Rules and any rules and principles of law that the Panel deems applicable, without the benefit of any response from Respondent.
RELIEF SOUGHT
Complainant requests that the Domain Name be transferred from Respondent to Complainant.
PARTIES' CONTENTIONS
A. Complainant
Complainant asserts common law rights in the BCA and BCA BENEFITS GROUP marks and an associated logo (the "BCA Marks") based on use in connection with employee benefits management services since at least 2014. Complainant asserts that it acquired the BCA Marks, their associated goodwill and rights in the Domain Name under a July 2018 Asset Purchase Agreement ("APA") between it and the principals of the BCA business, one of which is the Respondent. Respondent's <bcabenefitsgroup.com> Domain Name is confusingly similar to the BCA Marks because it wholly incorporates the BCA BENEFITS GROUP mark and adds the ".com" generic top-level domain ("gTLD").
Respondent does not have rights or legitimate interests in the <bcabenefitsgroup.com> domain name. Respondent is neither licensed to use the BCA Marks nor commonly known by the Domain Name. In 2014, prior to the sale of the business to the Complainant, Respondent registered the Domain Name in his own name while managing partner of the BCA business. Under the APA, Complainant acquired the rights to the Domain Name, but Respondent retained control of the registration after leaving Complainant in 2022. Respondent now uses the Domain Name to promote a competing business under confusingly similar branding, which is not a bona fide offering of services.
Respondent renewed and uses the <bcabenefitsgroup.com> domain name in bad faith. Respondent has retained control of the Domain Name despite Complainant's demand for transfer and renewed the registration in August 2026 with actual knowledge of Complainant's rights and in circumstances where, due to the operation of the APA, it has no basis to retain ownership of the Domain Name. This renewal satisfies the bad faith registration requirement, and Respondent now uses the Domain Name to attract Internet users for commercial gain by creating confusion as to affiliation with Complainant.
B. Respondent
Respondent failed to submit a Response in this proceeding.
FINDINGS
Complainant has failed to establish that the Domain Name was registered in bad faith in satisfaction of Policy ¶ 4(a)(iii) and thus its complaint must be denied. The Panel finds that the Complaint was brought in bad faith in an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking.
DISCUSSION
Paragraph 15(a) of the Rules instructs this Panel to "decide a complaint on the basis of the statements and documents submitted and in accordance with the Policy, these Rules and any rules and principles of law that it deems applicable."
Paragraph 4(a) of the Policy requires that Complainant must prove each of the following three elements to obtain an order that a domain name should be cancelled or transferred:
(1) the domain name registered by Respondent is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark in which Complainant has rights; and
(2) Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in respect of the domain name; and
(3) the domain name has been registered and is being used in bad faith.
In view of Respondent's failure to submit a response, the Panel shall decide this administrative proceeding on the basis of Complainant's undisputed representations pursuant to paragraphs 5(f), 14(a) and 15(a) of the Rules and draw such inferences it considers appropriate pursuant to paragraph 14(b) of the Rules. The Panel is entitled to accept all reasonable allegations set forth in a complaint; however, the Panel may deny relief where a complaint contains mere conclusory or unsubstantiated arguments. See WIPO Jurisprudential Overview 3.1 at ¶ 4.3; see also eGalaxy Multimedia Inc. v. ON HOLD By Owner Ready To Expire, FA 157287 (Forum June 26, 2003) ("Because Complainant did not produce clear evidence to support its subjective allegations [. . .] the Panel finds it appropriate to dismiss the Complaint").
Identical and/or Confusingly Similar
In light of the Panel's dispositive finding on the issue of registration and use in bad faith, the Panel declines to address the question of whether the Complainant has established common law rights in any of the BCA Marks.
Rights or Legitimate Interests
In light of the Panel's dispositive finding on the issue of registration and use in bad faith, the Panel declines to address the question of rights or legitimate interests.
Registration and Use in Bad Faith
The Panel finds that Complainant has failed to meet its burden of proof of bad faith registration and therefore has not satisfied Policy ¶ 4(a)(iii). See Tristar Products, Inc. v. Domain Administrator / Telebrands, Corp., FA 1597388 (Forum Feb. 16, 2015) ("Complainant makes conclusory allegations of bad faith but has adduced no specific evidence that warrants a holding that Respondent proceeded in bad faith at the time it registered the disputed domain name. Mere assertions of bad faith, even when made on multiple grounds, do not prove bad faith."); see also Chris Pearson v. Domain Admin / Automattic, Inc., FA 1613723 (Forum Jul. 3, 2015) (finding that the complainant could not establish the respondent registered and used the disputed domain name in bad faith because it failed to present evidence that would support such a holding).
On Complainant's own account, Respondent registered the Domain Name in 2014 while serving as managing partner of the BCA business, the business trading under the BCA Marks. The record does not establish that any common law rights in the BCA Marks had accrued by then. Even if such rights had already arisen, they would have belonged to the BCA business, from which Complainant claims to have acquired them under the APA. There is no evidence that Respondent acted in bad faith when he registered the Domain Name.
Complainant submits that Respondent's renewal of the Domain Name in August 2026 and his failure to transfer control of it as required by the APA amount to bad faith registration. This position has been overwhelmingly rejected by case law under the Policy, and Complainant, who is legally represented and cites a total of seven domain name dispute cases in support of its various contentions, should well be aware of this fact. See WIPO Overview 3.1 at ¶ 3.9 which states "Also, irrespective of registrant representations undertaken further to UDRP paragraph 2, panels have found that the mere renewal of a domain name registration by the same registrant is insufficient to support a finding of registration in bad faith." Complainant's reliance on Documo Inc. v. Matthew Herrera (now known as Matthew Valeo), WIPO Case No. DIO2023-0024 ("Documo"), is misplaced. That case was decided under the .IO policy, which permits a finding based on bad faith use alone. Equally Complainant's reference to Blue On Highland LLC v. Matthew Sullivan, WIPO Case No. D2021-3168 is irrelevant; in that case, the evidence supported an inference that the respondent acted opportunistically at the time of the original registration. The record here supports no such inference.
The Panel notes that even if the Panel were to accept Complainant's submissions that Respondent is engaging in sharp conduct in breach of the APA by retaining control of the Domain Name, such a finding only goes to the use of the Domain Name and not the registration and hence Complainant has failed to meet its burden of proof of bad faith registration and use under Policy ¶ 4(a)(iii); see Platterz v. Andrew Melcher, FA 1729887 (Forum June 19, 2017) ("Whatever the merits of Complainant's arguments that Respondent is using the Domain Name in bad faith, those arguments are irrelevant, as a complainant must prove both bad faith registration and bad faith use in order to prevail.").
The Panel considers the present proceeding is not a case of cybersquatting, rather it is a business dispute relating to the enforcement of a contract entered into several years after the Domain Name was entered into, and hence outside the scope of the Policy; see Everingham Bros. Bait Co. v. Contigo Visual, FA 440219 (Forum Apr. 27, 2005) (Forum Feb. 16, 2015) ("The Panel finds that this matter is outside the scope of the Policy because it involves a business dispute between two parties. The UDRP was implemented to address abusive cybersquatting, not contractual or legitimate business disputes."); see also Fuze Beverage, LLC v. CGEYE, Inc., FA 844252 (Forum Jan. 8, 2007) ("The Complaint before us describes what appears to be a common-form claim of breach of contract or breach of fiduciary duty. It is not the kind of controversy, grounded exclusively in abusive cyber-squatting, that the Policy was designed to address."); see also Patrick Shawn O'Grady v. Sam McKinley / CTI Ind., Inc., FA 1790052 (Forum June 22, 2018).
The Policy is designed to deal with clear cases of cybersquatting, see IAFT International LLC v. MANAGING DIRECTOR / EUTOPIAN HOLDINGS, FA 1577032 (Forum Oct. 9, 2014) ("The objectives of the Policy are limited -- designed to obviate the need for time-consuming and costly litigation in relatively clear cases of cyber-squatting -- and not intended to thwart every sort of questionable business practice imaginable. "). See also Courtney Love v. Brooke Barnett, FA 944826 (Forum May 14, 2007) ("the purpose of the Policy is not to resolve disputes between parties who might each have legitimate rights in a domain name. The purpose of the Policy is to protect trademark owners from cybersquatters, that is, from people who abuse the domain name system in a very specific way, which specific way is outlined in Paragraph 4(a) of the Policy."). The Panel wishes to make it clear that other remedies may be available to Complainant in a different forum, in particular forums that would allow for the determination and enforcement of any rights Complainant may have under the APA, and that nothing in this decision should be understood as providing a definitive finding on the respective rights of the parties, beyond the narrow question determined under this proceeding. However, this is not a case of cybersquatting and the Complainant has not established the right to the remedy it seeks under the Policy.
REVERSE DOMAIN NAME HIJACKING
Reverse Domain Name Hijacking ("RDNH") is defined in Rule 1 as "using the Policy in bad faith to attempt to deprive a registered domain-name holder of a domain name". Rule 15(e) provides, in part:
"If after considering the submissions the Panel finds that the complaint was brought in bad faith, for example in an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking or was brought primarily to harass the domain-name holder, the Panel shall declare in its decision that the complaint was brought in bad faith and constitutes an abuse of the administrative proceeding."
The WIPO Overview 3.1 at ¶ 4.16 states in respect of RDNH:
"Panels have consistently found that the mere lack of success of a complaint is not itself sufficient for a finding of RDNH...
Reasons articulated by panels for finding RDNH include: (i) facts which demonstrate that the complainant knew it could not succeed as to any of the required three elements – such as the complainant's lack of relevant trademark rights, clear knowledge of respondent rights or legitimate interests, or clear knowledge of a lack of respondent bad faith (see generally section 3.8) such as registration of the disputed domain name well before the complainant acquired trademark rights, (ii) facts which demonstrate that the complainant clearly ought to have known it could not succeed under any fair interpretation of facts reasonably available prior to the filing of the complaint, including relevant facts on the website at the disputed domain name or readily available public sources such as the WhoIs database, (iii) unreasonably ignoring established Policy precedent notably as captured in this WIPO Overview – except in limited circumstances which prima facie justify advancing an alternative legal argument, (iv) the provision of false evidence, or otherwise attempting to mislead the panel, (v) the provision of intentionally incomplete material evidence – often clarified by the respondent, (vi) the complainant's failure to disclose that a case is a UDRP refiling, (vii) filing the complaint after an unsuccessful attempt to acquire the disputed domain name from the respondent without a plausible legal basis, (viii) basing a complaint on only the barest of allegations without any supporting evidence."
The Panel considers that, at a minimum, items (i) and (iii) exist in the present proceeding. Specifically:
· Complainant knew when it filed the Complaint that Respondent registered the Domain Name in 2014 while serving as managing partner of the business it later acquired. On Complainant's own account, the Domain Name was likely registered before any common law rights in those marks arose. Even if such rights had already accrued, they would have belonged to the business Respondent managed. Complainant knew these circumstances and should have known that it could not establish that Respondent registered the Domain Name in bad faith.
· Complainant is represented by sophisticated counsel who cite seven decisions in support of its contentions, six under the UDRP and one under the .IO policy. Its case on bad faith registration nevertheless relies on the theory that Respondent's renewal of the Domain Name amounted to re-registration. That theory is contrary to well-settled case law reflected in the WIPO Overview 3.1 at ¶ 3.9. Complainant does not address this case law in its submissions, rather it cherry-picks a single case from 2013 (Bear River Mutual Insurance Company v. Dzone Inc. FA 1528522 (Forum Dec. 11, 2013)) without acknowledging the overwhelming precedent to the contrary.
· At paragraph 41 of the Complaint, Complainant quotes Documo Inc. v. Matthew Herrera (now known as Matthew Valeo), WIPO Case No. DIO2023-0024. The quoted passage correctly states that the UDRP requires proof of both bad faith registration and bad faith use. Complainant nevertheless emphasises the words "the Policy requires only that either of these things be shown", without explaining that "the Policy" in that passage refers to the .IO policy, under which either bad faith registration or bad faith use suffices. The immediately preceding sentence in Documo expressly distinguishes the two policies. Omitting that context obscures why the panel in Documo could grant relief on a finding of bad faith use alone.
· At paragraph 42, Complainant relies on Documo for the proposition that a respondent acts in bad faith by refusing to transfer a domain name whose rights have been validly assigned. The panel in Documo found expressly found that the refusal constituted bad faith use, which was sufficient under the .IO policy but is insufficient under the URDP. Read together, paragraphs 41 and 42 give a materially misleading account of what Documo establishes under Policy ¶ 4(a)(iii). Even if Respondent's later conduct amounted to bad faith use, Complainant still had to establish bad faith registration.
At paragraph 50 of the Complaint, Complainant gave the certification required by Rule 3(b)(xiii). It certified that, to the best of its knowledge, the information in the Complaint was complete and accurate and that its assertions were warranted under the Rules and applicable law as it exists or as it may be extended by a good-faith and reasonable argument. The Panel finds that Complainant failed to comply with that certification. By omitting the distinction between the two policies and relying on Documo as it did, Complainant presented the decision in a materially incomplete and misleading way on an issue central to the Complaint. Complainant advanced no good-faith and reasonable argument for extending the UDRP to permit relief on proof of bad faith use alone.
For these reasons, taken together with the circumstances of the original registration and Complainant's reliance on the renewal of the Domain Name as being sufficient to show registration in bad faith, the Panel concludes that the Complaint was brought in bad faith in an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking and constitutes an abuse of the administrative proceeding.
DECISION
Having not established all three elements required under the ICANN Policy, the Panel concludes that relief shall be DENIED. The Panel further finds that the Complaint was brought in bad faith and constitutes an abuse of the administrative proceeding.
Accordingly, it is Ordered that the <bcabenefitsgroup.com> domain name REMAIN WITH Respondent.
Nicholas J.T. Smith, Panelist
Dated: November 12, 2026
Click Here to return to the main Domain Decisions Page.
Click Here to return to our Home Page